Spring 2011 TREE Fund Report: TREE Fund Research Update: Lingering Ash
Return to Table of Contents – Spring 2011 TREE Fund Report
TREE Fund Research Update: Lingering Ash Survivors of the Emerald Ash Borer Invasion
Contributed by: 
Daniel A. Herms, Dept. of Entomology,  OARDC, The Ohio State University
 Kathleen Knight, Northern Research Station, US  Forest Service, East Lansing,   MI
 Jennifer L. Koch, Northern Research Station, US  Forest Service, Delaware,  OH
 Therese Poland, Northern Research Station, US  Forest Service, East Lansing,   MI
The emerald ash borer (EAB)  is an invasive, non-native  insect that has been responsible for devastation of  the ash resource,  both in the nursery industry and in our forested landscapes,  since it  was discovered in the Detroit  area in 2002.   Initial   reports following the outbreak of EAB in urban areas indicated that  there was  no resistance to this insect. Such urban trees are usually a  limited  representation of a few horticultural selections of the  species.  As the beetle spread into more  genetically diverse native  stands and woodlots, over 250 plots were established  throughout  Michigan and Ohio to monitor the impact of EAB.  In some areas where EAB  has been present for  several years and almost all of the ash trees are  dead, a small number of ash  trees persisted-about one in  one-thousand.   Researchers from the U.S. Forest Service and The Ohio  State University  have initiated work to preserve these “lingering ash” –  the last remnant of the  regional ash resource-through grafting.   In  addition, researchers are using various bioassays to determine if  these  trees possess rare genes that allow them to resist invasion by EAB, or  if  they are simply the last trees to die. Foliar feeding studies using  adult  beetles demonstrated that some of the lingering ash selections  are indeed  significantly less preferred relative to horticultural  cultivars and seedlings  of the same species.  Further support of  this  finding was inadvertently obtained when an EAB outbreak at the Forest   Service ash rearing facility in Delaware,  OH resulted in the  infestation of horticultural cultivars growing alongside  lingering ash  selections, but the lingering ash remained uninfested.  These lingering  ash trees will be used in  breeding programs to further enhance  EAB-resistance, develop a seed source for  restoration of ash, and  develop new cultivars that will restore the status of  ash as a  profitable ornamental tree in the nursery industry.
Initial   reports following the outbreak of EAB in urban areas indicated that  there was  no resistance to this insect. Such urban trees are usually a  limited  representation of a few horticultural selections of the  species.  As the beetle spread into more  genetically diverse native  stands and woodlots, over 250 plots were established  throughout  Michigan and Ohio to monitor the impact of EAB.  In some areas where EAB  has been present for  several years and almost all of the ash trees are  dead, a small number of ash  trees persisted-about one in  one-thousand.   Researchers from the U.S. Forest Service and The Ohio  State University  have initiated work to preserve these “lingering ash” –  the last remnant of the  regional ash resource-through grafting.   In  addition, researchers are using various bioassays to determine if  these  trees possess rare genes that allow them to resist invasion by EAB, or  if  they are simply the last trees to die. Foliar feeding studies using  adult  beetles demonstrated that some of the lingering ash selections  are indeed  significantly less preferred relative to horticultural  cultivars and seedlings  of the same species.  Further support of  this  finding was inadvertently obtained when an EAB outbreak at the Forest   Service ash rearing facility in Delaware,  OH resulted in the  infestation of horticultural cultivars growing alongside  lingering ash  selections, but the lingering ash remained uninfested.  These lingering  ash trees will be used in  breeding programs to further enhance  EAB-resistance, develop a seed source for  restoration of ash, and  develop new cultivars that will restore the status of  ash as a  profitable ornamental tree in the nursery industry.
